| 1993 | 1994 | |||
| D | Kate Beemer (WI) | G | Megan Miller (IL) | |
| D | Samantha Edelson (IL) | D | Myranda Hayes (WI) | |
| D | Gabby Grandin (WI) | D | Casey Maciejewski (IL) | |
| D | Josie Johnson (WI) | D | Kelly Micholson (IL) | |
| F | Hannah Bielawski (IL) | D | Katie Kim (IL) | |
| F | Mary DeBartolo (IL) | D | Hannah Zobel (WI) | |
| F | Kim Drake (WI) | F | Eileen Harris (IL) | |
| F | Jackie Wand (IL) | F | Rachel Jones (WI) | |
| F | Morgan Madill (MO) | |||
| F | Jenna Marks (WI) | |||
| F | Lauren Roethlisberger (WI) | |||
| 1995 | 1996 | |||
| G | Sidney Peters (IL) | G | Leah Patrick (WI) | |
| G | Leigh Grall (WI) | D | Emma Kohl (WI) | |
| D | Brittany Anderson (WI) | D | Megan Ondrick (IL) | |
| D | Savannah Harmon (IL) | D | Maddie Rolfes (Midwest) | |
| D | Sydnee Saracco (IL) | D | Natahsa Smith (WI) | |
| D | Taylor Willard (IL) | D | Emma Turbyville (IL) | |
| F | Hannah Gavic (WI) | F | Sarah Bobrowski (WI) | |
| F | Claudia Kepler (WI) | F | Ilana Heaton (IL) | |
| F | Katie Matheny (MO) | F | Cynthia Kyin (IL) | |
| F | Fiona McKenna (IL) | F | Bailey Larson (IL) | |
| F | Samantha O'Brien (WI) | F | Katherine Roznik (WI) | |
| F | Cara Piazza (IL) | F | Arianna Smith (WI) | |
| F | Baylee Wellhausen (WI) | |||
| F | Grace Zarzecki (IL) | |||